The Rejection Club

The Rejection Club

by Jeannie Ruesch

Along the way to publication of my first novel, SOMETHING ABOUT HER, rejection was a part of the game.  After the second agent-requested-partial-turned-rejection,  I found myself turning to the internet in search of other sad souls who felt the same disappointment, depression and urge to curl up inside a big, fuzzy blanket and never come out.

I had become a member of the Illustrious Rejection Club, a dark warehouse with a dreary facade and an old, wooden carved sign barely hanging on for dear life by one hook.  You certainly do not want to walk through those doors.  You want to be in that shiny, sparkly building just a little further down the street with the flashy, neon sign pronouncing all who enter “Published and Proud.”  If you’re lucky, you get the hand stamp that never comes off.

However, once a rejection letter has crossed your desk, you are a part of The Illustrious Rejection Club.  You have no choice but to walk inside those heavy double doors.

And when you do?  The doors shut behind you, and immediately, Gloria Gaynor’s voice seems to burst from the black walls to tell you You will survive.  You realize you hate this song, and wonder if The Illustrious Rejection Club is simply a pseudonym for Hell. But still, you find yourself walking to the beat…and even (under your breath so no one could possibly hear you) singing along …”you think I’d crumble, you think I’d lay down and die…Oh no, not I.”

You keep walking.  The hallway seems endless, just like the length of time you know it will take before you would be considered good enough to serve drinks in the Published and Proud building.  As you meander your way through the turns and twists, you hear inklings of life.  Voices.  Laughter even.

Laughter? In the Rejection Club?  No one should be laughing.  We should all be sitting in our respective corners, nursing a pound of melted chocolate.

Intrigued, you step a little livelier.  And as you round that last corner, amazement and awe fill you.  For here, in this room where you now belong, are hundreds (tens of hundreds, even) of writers just like you.  They mill about, chatting with each other, sharing stories.  In one corner of the room, they shoot darts at their respective rejection letters and cheer for the bulls eyes.  In another corner is a giant chocolate fountain available to dip any number of food items in.  Hmm. If this is Hell, it’s not so bad.

The minute you step into the room, every gaze is directed at you.  The heavy spotlight of recognition doesn’t sit well, until you focus on the smiles.  They beckon you in to join them.

And you recognize those faces.

Meg Cabot hefts a US Postal Bag she keeps the many rejection letters she received and waves at you.

Christina Dodd proudly bears a “25 rejections and 3 manuscripts” button on her lapel.

Stephen King lounges on a couch and points up at the spike he hammered into the wall, full of rejection slips.

Julia Quinn gestures you to sit next to her at the Hot Chocolate Bar and tells you that in her rejections, “one said that the story was great but the characters were obvious, another said that the characters were great but the story was lame.  And another said that the characters were likable but the story was too simplistic and the heroine was not believable (somewhat inexplicably despite the fact that the characters were likable.)   So there was no big consensus on why I wasn’t worth publishing.” (1)

As you get up and move around the room, you see Nora Roberts.  The button on her lapel says “Years of rejections.”  This from the first woman to be inducted into the RWA Hall of Fame.  Whose last million books have been best sellers.

Perhaps this room isn’t so bad a place to be after all.

At the back of the room is a large mural.  Curious, you work your way toward it.  The wall is full of reviews and rejections for names that have you dropping your jaw:

Shakespeare’s name, you may depend on it, stands absurdly too high and will go down. He had no invention as to stories, none whatever. He took all his plots from old novels, and threw their stories into a dramatic shape, at as little expense of thought as you or I could turn his plays back again into prose tales.”— Lord Byron, letter to James Hogg  1814

“Mr. F. Scott Fitzgerald deserves a good shaking … The Great Gatsby is an absurd story, whether considered as romance, melodrama, or plain record of New York high life.” – Saturday Review of LiteratureMary Higgins Clark was rejected on Journey Back To Love, 1962, with “We found the heroine as boring as her husband had.”

Disney wasn’t infallible, either: “Snow White will sound the Disney death knell.” Critic in the publication, “Current History”.

Jean Auel, author of The Clan of Cave Bear was told, “We are very impressed with the depth and scope of your research and the quality of your prose. Nevertheless … we don’t think we could distribute enough copies to satisfy you or ourselves.”

Dr. Seuss received harsh rejection, as well: “…too different from other juveniles on the market to warrant its selling.”

Jack London heard, “(Your book is) forbidding and depressing.”

The Diary of Anne Frank, by Anne Frank, was rejected by 15 publishers before Doubleday picked it up.

As you walk away from the Wall of Rejected Greats, the weight in your chest has lightened.  These are all terrific writers.  And they stand in the same room you do right now.

Certainly they are frequent dwellers in the building down the street, but this building… this Club is where they, too, began.  And that other building? The shiny, sparkly one you so desperately aspire to?

It’s only a few steps away.

So in the meantime, settle in with a cup of hot chocolate and enjoy the view of writers and more who have joined the Illustrious Rejection Club at one time in their career.    As Joyce Spizer writes, “‘No’ is a word on your path to `Yes.’


The Rejection Club

Jeannie Ruesch | 


“A wonderful debut! Jeannie Ruesch writes with tremendous heart.” — Gaelen Foley, NY Times Bestselling Author of HER EVERY PLEASURE

12 Responses to The Rejection Club

  1. Jeannie

    Rayka — that’s so important, giving yourself the time to be upset, brood, or do whatever you do when something gets you down. (Voo doo dolls anyone? *grin* )

    You have the perfect way of dealing with things and then moving on, I think.


  2. Jeannie

    Hi MarthaE– Very true, most successful people have faced failure. You have to be willing to accept it, embrace it at times and persevere in spite of it. I mean, imagine if ANY of the people we have mentioned on this post stopped?

    Randy Pausch was a professor who passed away earlier this year ( or late last year) and he has a very inspiring video out there… (youtube his name). He basically says that the brick walls aren’t there to stop us, they are there to help us decide how badly we want something. The only person who can make you quit is you. Or me. Or whomever. LOL 🙂

  3. Jeannie

    Hi Lori — It’s true, we writers are a unique breed. How many people do you know who face rejection on an almost daily basis in such a big way? It’s not easy, but it’s a part of the game. Just remember that, when it has you depressed. It’s just part of your journey to the top. 🙂

  4. Jeannie

    Hi Carol — What a great story! It’s amazing to think some of the people we now recognize as top of their field, enterprising or just plain amazing were once considered not worth it. Everyone has their time, I really believe that. 🙂

    Thanks for commenting!

  5. Jeannie

    Pam, hello back and thank you!

    Yes, the stories I’ve read/heard about authors and other famous sorts being rejected is astounding. So it makes me realize when agents and editors say this is a subjective business, it means it IS a subjective business. I’ve never been one to let one (or two or twenty) voices tell me not to do something. 🙂

  6. Rayka Mennen

    What a great post! I give myself one day/evening to be upset about a rejection. Over a martini or two, I allow myself to fume, grieve, mumble, cast aspersions on the reviewer’s authority, etc. The next day, my frustration cleansed, I am back at the computer (either figuring out how to fix this submission or tailor it to someone else).

  7. MarthaE

    Hi Jeannie – that is a great approach to rejection…. sort of like the “don’t be so embarrassed – we’ve all done that/been there (or could have been!) Club!! I’m not a writer (see- I haven’t even gotten brave enough to try!!) but I can relate to the other Club! Like any good, worthwhile endeavor, it takes courage and persistence! I think that is why I appreciated the book Failing Forward by John Maxwell. Most successful people have had their share of failure along the way!

  8. Lori Brighton

    What a great post! I have been so depressed by rejections, but you’re right, everyone experiences them. And no one but another writer understands the pain you go through.

  9. Carol L.

    I can’t believe some of the Authors who received rejection letters either. But they stuck with it and everyone has to start somewhere, right ? Determination usually pays off. I read whre George Lucas from Star Wars was told in college that his robots , CP30 and R2D2 and his imagination were not going to take him anywhere and he should change his major. Wonder who laughed the loudest. 🙂
    Carol L.

  10. Pam S


    I really admire all of you who keep going after the dreaded rejection letters. I have heard that it has taken some writers years before they got accepted by a publisher. Kudos to all of you who keep going, so glad you did there are some awesome stories out there!

    Your book looks great btw I will have to check it out!

  11. Jeannie

    Hi Cheryl — Thanks! Yes, it’s gratifying in a twisted way, isn’t it? LOL

    I remember my hubby looked at me one day, when we were talking about the ebb and flow of being on Top of your game (ala Nora Roberts) and saying that she started off just like we did.

    I remember hearing that someone told Garth Brooks he would never amount to a singer. I believe that man is probably flipping burgers about now. LOL

    Rejection is a part of the game, but it’s only one part…keep trying, and eventually you’ll get past it.

  12. Cheryl McInnis

    Great post Jeannie! I never realized that so many wonderful writers started off with rejections.

    It reminds me of an article that I read once that said when Babe Ruth held the record for the most home runs, he also held the record for the most strike outs! Thank goodness we human beings are a stubborn bunch and keep on trying no matter what~

Back to Top